Press "Enter" to skip to content

Farmers vs Modi by Dhruv Rathee

Spread the love

The Truth Behind MSP: Understanding the Reality of the Farming Industry by Dhruv Rathee, Farmers VS Modi

Introduction to MSP and MRP

MSP, or Minimum Support Price, is the minimum amount that would be paid to the farmers for their crops. It was established to protect farmers from exploitation by companies and middlemen. On the other hand, MRP, or Maximum Retail Price, is the highest price at which products can be sold in the market. MRP exists to protect consumers from exploitation. MSP and MRP are essential to maintain fairness in the agriculture and consumer sectors, respectively.

Understanding the MSP Formula

The MSP formula is based on the recommendations of the High-Level Committee on Long Term Grain Policy. This committee suggested that MSP should be based on the C2 cost of production, which includes the comprehensive cost of production. The comprehensive cost includes the A2 and FL costs, along with the cost of owned capital assets and rental value of land. The formula for determining MSP is essential to ensure that farmers receive a fair and equitable price for their produce.

ALSO READ : How Indian Software Engineer Industry is CHANGING in 2024

The Swaminathan Report and Its Recommendations

The Swaminathan Report, released between 2004 and 2006, highlighted the need for MSP to be at least 50% more than the Weighted Average Cost of Production. The report spanned almost 2,000 pages, and it was mentioned that the MSP should be calculated at C2 cost plus 50%, with procurement, storage, and distribution costs included. The report also emphasized the importance of post-harvest costs to be considered, in addition to the C2 cost. It recommended that MSP should not only be applied to the government but also to private traders, and it should be considered as a bottom line to prevent anyone from buying produce cheaper than the MSP. Furthermore, the report suggested that farmers’ income should be comparable to that of civil servants, and it proposed the establishment of more than 50,000 farm schools all over the country to empower farmers through innovation and knowledge. The report also stressed the need for food grain banks in villages to prepare for natural calamities. The report offered a comprehensive vision for the empowerment and protection of farmers in India.

The Impact of Farm Laws and Media Propaganda

The passing of the three farm laws in India revealed significant implications for the farming industry. The laws were perceived to favor corporates over farmers, giving large corporate companies an advantage in various aspects of agricultural trade. This move was met with widespread protest, underscoring the importance of MSP as a safety net for farmers’ livelihoods. Despite the need for MSP, media propaganda has been used to spread misinformation and discredit the farmers’ demands. False claims about the economic impact of implementing MSP, ranging from ₹10 Trillion to ₹18 Trillion, have been debunked, with the real cost estimated to be only around ₹210 billion for the marketing year 2023. Furthermore, the burden of buying at MSP would primarily fall on private players, particularly middlemen and corporate companies who are already earning substantial profits. The need for MSP in the agricultural industry is akin to the minimum wage law in other sectors, ensuring fair compensation for farmers and balancing the power dynamics in agricultural trade. The impact of MSP on the free market principle has also been questioned, emphasizing the need to understand the complexities of the market before forming an opinion. In summary, the implementation of MSP is vital for the economic viability and empowerment of farmers, and media propaganda should not detract from the genuine need for fair compensation in the agricultural sector.

READ MORE : New Google DSA Course Launched : The Top Free Resource for Learning Data Structures & Algorithms in 2024

Economic Viability of Farming and the Importance of MSP

Farming is a crucial part of the Indian economy, providing sustenance for a large portion of the population. However, the economic viability of farming is under threat, and the implementation of MSP (Minimum Support Price) is essential to address this challenge. Here’s why MSP is crucial for the economic viability of farming:

MSP as a Safety Net for Farmers

MSP serves as a safety net for farmers, ensuring that they receive a fair and equitable price for their produce. Without MSP, farmers are at the mercy of market fluctuations and can be exploited by middlemen and corporate players in the agricultural trade. MSP provides a minimum price guarantee, preventing farmers from selling their produce at significantly lower prices than the cost of production.

ALSO READ : Success Story: Aravind Secures AIR 51 in GATE CS 2024

Protecting Small Farmers and Ensuring Fair Compensation

Small farmers, who own less than 3 acres of land, face significant challenges in making a viable profit from their farming activities. MSP ensures that these small farmers are fairly compensated for their efforts, providing them with a reliable source of income. Additionally, MSP incentivizes the cultivation of crops that may not be as profitable in the open market but are essential for environmental sustainability and public health.

Impact of MSP on Agricultural Trade

The implementation of MSP does not burden the government alone. Private traders and corporate entities are also expected to adhere to MSP regulations, ensuring fair compensation for farmers across the board. This aligns with the principles of minimum wage laws in other sectors, where the government mandates fair compensation for labor.

Role of MSP in Balancing Power Dynamics

MSP plays a crucial role in balancing power dynamics in agricultural trade, ensuring that farmers have a bargaining position and are not subject to exploitation by larger players in the market. It serves as a necessary intervention to protect the interests of farmers and maintain a level playing field in the agricultural sector.

For More Update Join My WhatsApp Channel Click Here

 

 

 

 

6 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *